NSW Government monitoring bore in The Pilliga
Santos’ Response to Submissions to the Narrabri Gas Project was released on 23 April 2018 and is on the NSW Government Planning & Environment website. The project now moves into the government assessment phase of the approval process.
A brief appraisal of Santos Response to Submissions reveals –
- The project has been delayed a year.
- A final investment decision has not been made due to the timing of approval, further appraisal and exploration.
- Over the life of the project an average of only 540 full time jobs will be created.
- Santos needs to make a development application or apply for a modification to expand the project area.
- Santos is not seeking approval for fracking.
Note: Modifications to a project do not require a separate EIS, a full assessment or community consultation. Fracking has occurred in NSW under a modification.
Insufficient monitoring and inadequate information were objected to strongly in the submissions. Many of the issues raised have still not been addressed as Santos proposes –
- A rehabilitation plan will be prepared post approval.
- Every 3 years a third party will do an environmental audit, monitoring gas wells and gathering lines.
- Waste salt, filter cartridges and reverse osmosis membranes will be disposed of at an appropriately licenced facility in accordance with regulatory requirements.
- Prior to a routine loadout to an off-site licenced management waste facility, the salt would be temporarily stored at Leewood, in a weatherproof appropriately bunded storage facility.
Note: In Queensland toxic salt piles up on gas companies’ or contractors land waiting for a waste facility to be approved and licenced.
Scientist wrote in their submissions that the information on the effects on surface and groundwater was insufficient to assess the project and more monitoring was needed. The water section is complex and expert advice is needed to see if Santos have adequately addressed this issue.
In other words this massive document does little to quash the fears of objectors but spins a good yarn. With the $13B takeover bid from US owned Harbour Energy being reviewed by the Foreign Investment Review Board, Santos needs to keep up appearances that this project is still viable.
The backyard of New South Wales is facing its biggest threat yet – invasive gasfields. Betrayal by governments has meant protectors are fighting to save the things they love. The Pilliga, Great Artesian Basin, Liverpool Plains – all are at risk. This is a David and Goliath battle to save our land, air and water from destruction. It’s also a fight for the soul and future of Australia. Meet the experts and people living in the sacrifice zone and uncover the truth behind the real gas crisis confronting ordinary Australians.
View Sacrifice Zone Continue reading
Spring into the Pilliga was held 10-12 November at Pilliga Pottery. Around 250 attended the event, participating in tours of the area, bushwalking, workshops and a campaign planning meeting. Continue reading
Many of the concerns raised in objections to the Narrabri Gas Project have also been raised by the Commonwealth Government’s Independent Expert Scientific Committee. The Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for the Project lacks baseline data and reveals an inadequate groundwater monitoring system, leading to modelling uncertainty.
Objectors are calling for no decision to be made on this Project until frequent monitoring over at least another three years, preferably five, provides adequate baseline data. More data needs to be collected on the geology, hydrology and stygofauna of the area to prove that this industry will not put the water resources at risk now or into the future. The data needs to be made public, and be further scrutinised by independent scientists.
Link to Independent Expert Scientific Committee on the Narrabri Gas Project EIS
Sydney Morning Herald article by Peter Hannam – ‘Low Confidence’: Expert panel raises concerns about Santos’ coal seam gas impacts
Santos’ Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for the Narrabri Gas Project received 22,700 submissions against it, well over the previous record of under 10,000 received by the NSW Government Planning & Environment Department. Submissions closed on May 22. I assumed the government would be assessing the submissions before allowing further developments but no, on July 3 they they granted APA the right to survey for a pipeline for the unapproved project. Continue reading
If the proposed Narrabri Gas Project is to go ahead, it has to connect to existing gas pipelines. APA has entered into an agreement with Santos to work with regulatory authorities and local communities towards the development of a new pipeline from the Project to the Moomba Sydney Pipeline near Condobolin. Continue reading
Produced salt and water
A school science project has been launched to enable Years 9 to 12 to understand some of the impacts of coal seam gas on the environment.
Using the Narrabri Gas Project’s Environmental Impact Statement they calculate the amount of salt and water extracted from the coal seam, research reverse osmosis and evaluate environmental effects.
You too can do this project and then have your say about this project by writing a submission to the NSW government. Click here for Science Project and submission information.
The Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for Santos’ Narrabri Gas Project in now online. Public submissions can be made up until 22 May. Environmental groups are calling for an extension due to the size of the EIS and the affects it will have on communities, productive farmland and water sources, including the Great Artesian Basin.
Concerns include the integrity of 850 wells drilled through the Great Artesian Basin to the coal seam below; the ‘treated’ waste water being allowed to run into the creek and river system; and the location of the landfill where the left over solid toxic salts will be buried. During a two year peak period, Santos estimates 2.5 B-double truck loads of toxic salt will be buried in landfill a day. Will this landfill site be near you?
Gas flare in The Pilliga
Nearly a year has passed since my last visit to the Pilliga and there are some notable changes. All the old rusted well heads have been cleaned up and painted dark green or hidden in boxes of the same colour. Many more signs are displayed on well gates, and line the roads where the pipes are laid. The new reverse osmosis plant installed by Santos last year is mostly hidden from public view, but it is clearly temporary as it is made up of a series of containers. Compared to the enormous Queensland plants, it is a toy. In conclusion, the Narrabri Gas Project is a neat, pretty gas field, with minimal infrastructure. It may fool politicians and the public but investors are not stupid, they have been to a real gas field and this isn’t one yet. Continue reading